Sometimes the truth is difficult to hear … or dangerous to tell. Sometimes, you have to serve it up with a helping of irony. And sometimes, you really DO have to use a spoonful of sugar to help the medicine go down. Such is the case with Count Basie’s classic 1940 record, “It’s The Same Old South.”

Debuted in the satirical labor revue “Meet the People,” Jay Gorney penned the music to this infectious, swingin’ tune that packed dance floors across the country. While at the same time, Ed Eliscu’s subversive lyrics told a story quite different from the history books. Life as a Black person in American society wasn’t as cheery as it appeared on the surface.

“It’s The Same Old South” brilliantly depicts our society as a study in contrast. Like the song, the story of the American way can sound sweet and melodic. But listen a little closer, and the lyrics of child labor, tar & feathering, and bloodhounds chasing union organizers declare that the beautiful landscape of the United States wasn’t so lovely after all.

This episode of “Soundtrack to the Struggle” was written and produced by Ron Adkins and hosted by Hollis Monroe.

January 23, 1943. Carnegie Hall. Duke Ellington and His Orchestra make their debut at the legendary venue. On the program is the premiere of Ellington’s new magnum opus – his three movement jazz symphony, “Black, Brown & Beige.” It is Ellington’s longest and most ambitious composition to date. Admittedly, the piece as a whole is under-rehearsed and rough in spots. But Duke is excited to use this stage-of-all-stages to make a grand statement on the Black condition.

He dubbed it, “a tonal parallel to the history of the Negro in America.” Within each movement, suites reflect components of the African-American experience, from slavery to Harlem to swing. Tympani portray the sounds of hard labor. Muted trumpets echo wails and work songs. There are spirituals and dance numbers. The work is rich and orchestral, but most assuredly jazz. Ellington makes sure his audience knows that jazz is America’s music – created by Black Americans.

Critical response to the Carnegie Hall performance is, at best, mixed. Discouraged by its tepid response, Ellington only performs “Black, Brown and Beige” once more before breaking it into pieces. Yet those pieces, like “Work Song,” and “Come Sunday,” collectively make the most powerful statement of all: We’ve come so far, but still have so far to go.

This episode of “Soundtrack to the Struggle” was written and produced by Ron Adkins. Executive Producers Dennis Green and George Dorman. Hosted by Hollis Monroe.

Podcast (soundtrack): Play in new window | Download

Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | RSS